Just Another Weekend: A Former Ohioan Remembers the Palm Sunday Tornadoes

I recently received a comment from one of my readers in response to my post on some rare photos of the 1965 Palm Sunday Tornadoes. Jim Stewart resides in Atlanta, Georgia, where he is the morning host and operations manager for WMVV 90.7 FM NewLife Radio. On the day of the tornadoes, though, Jim was a nine-year-old boy living near Lima, Ohio.

In response to his comment on my blog, I invited Jim to share his experience of the storms. He has done so, and to a degree that goes well beyond a mere comment. Jim took time and thought, and has supplied a fascinating, well-written, very personal remembrance of that fateful evening.

No need for me to say more. It”s time for Jim to tell his story, which he calls…

Just Another Weekend

(C) 2009, Jim Stewart

When you are young, time passes slowly, and sometimes it’s a monotonous routine. Monday moves into Tuesday, the week passes, and another ordinary weekend comes and goes. But then there are the times and events that bring change, shaping our lives, our thinking, and our emotions. Such was the Palm Sunday weekend of April 1965.

I grew up as an only child in and near Lima in Allen County, Ohio. Thunderstorms, wind, blizzards, droughts, and the like were commonplace in the Midwest. But what was brewing on that fateful weekend was different.

At nine years of age I was in the fourth grade at Shawnee Elementary School, a rather shy kid without many friends. On Friday of that fateful weekend I became progressively ill in class. I stayed for the full day, but was immediately ushered to bed as soon as I got home when my mother found I had a high fever. Our home at the time was located on Ft. Amanda Road near the intersection with Shawnee Road in the Shawnee Township area, about four miles southwest of Lima.

On Saturday morning, I was taken to the doctor to be checked out. The weather was partly sunny, and cool enough that a jacket was necessary. After being treated for the virus, apparently contracted at school, I spent the rest of the day convalescing on the living room couch. That afternoon my father and I watched a Reds game live from Cincinnati that was played under mostly sunny skies. Everyone in the Great Lakes area was totally oblivious to the terror that would move though the region in just over twenty-four hours.

Sunday dawned in a very strange way, at least to me as a young child, as a heavy thunderstorm raged outside with all the ingredients you would expect in the afternoon or evening of a spring day. It was actually a strong warm front pushing its way northward, ushering in very warm, moist, and unstable air to the region along with an unusually strong jet stream high above, a harbinger of the main event now just a few hours away.

The remainder of that morning is rather sketchy. My parents went to church, and I was left at home with my Great, Great Aunt May, who was living with us at the time. I remember that the weather cleared, and by afternoon the sun was shining. My father and I again watched television, the Master’s Golf Tournament from Augusta, Georgia, with bright sunlight streaming through the western windows of the living room. I never ventured outside that afternoon due to my illness, but I do know it had warmed considerably from the previous day.

In the early evening I was feeling better. My parents went to evening church services and my Aunt May looked after me as we continued to watch television. At the time there were no severe weather watches or warnings broadcast, although tornadoes were already occurring to our far west and northwest.

We were watching local channel 35 WIMA-TV as the Wonderful World of Disney came on at 7:30 P.M. and darkness fell. As the program continued, I noticed a strobe-like flashing in the southwestern sky. The flashing was nearly constant and becoming brighter as time passed. Aunt May, who was setting next to a window, became very nervous as she moved to another chair in the interior of the room for fear that the lightning was going to strike her. Strangely, the thunder had yet to be heard, indicating that we were observing a very strong electrical storm still a distance away but moving our way.

By 8:30 P.M. the storm was more to the west-northwest still putting out a large lightning display, but not quite as intense as earlier. There were still no severe weather statements on local television.

nJust before 9:00 P.M. my parents returned home from church in time to watch Bonanza. They did not say much about the approaching storm other than that there was a lot of lightning going on in the northwest. Soon after Bonanza began WIMA-TV finally broadcast a vague weather alert from the weather service in Toledo that called for “…severe thunderstorms with a tornado or two till 10:00 P.M.” No references were given to any specific counties as tornadoes raged in several locations at that moment; unfortunately this lack of warning likely caused many fatalities.

Around 9:15 P.M. the storm suddenly seemed to explode just to our north in a way I had never seen before nor have seen since as vivid lightning of green, pink, white, orange, and blue lit the sky. I did not realize that the blue flashes were likely not lightning, but rather, power line flashes and transformer explosions as the tornado bisected Allen County just eight miles north of our home. Even the reception from WIMA-TV, located about five miles north-northeast of us, became so bad that it was unwatchable as the storm passed by. We had to switch to another station from Dayton, some sixty-five miles to the south, using our VHF roof antenna. During the time we watched this station, it came in unusually strong, as if it was local. There were some very strange atmospheric phenomenons transpiring for these few moments as the storm traversed the area.

The storm began to move out to the northeast as strong west southwest winds began to buffet our home. The cold front that generated the storm had arrived ending the severe storm threat. I went to bed having no idea of the destruction that had been and was still taking place all around our region. What is now rated as the third largest tornado outbreak in history had left in its wake over 250 dead, thousands injured, and an untold number of homes, businesses, and churches reduced to rubble. The wind howled most of the night as I lay in my comfortable bed, but we didn’t even lose power. We were blessed.

Monday morning dawned bright and sunny. My mother was listening to a local radio station as it ran continuous reports about the tornado that ripped Allen County in half the previous evening. The radio station even had a news correspondent in an airplane reporting live on the damage as he flew over the storm’s path, a rather innovative feat for the time. Feeling better as far as my illness was concerned, I stayed home from school just to be sure I was totally over the virus, but I was feeling rather strange about this unexpected event that was unknowingly affecting my life.

Many stories began to surface after the tornado blew through. My father, a pipe fitter and welder, was working in Toledo at the time and made an early Monday morning drive to work each week. On the morning of April 12 he saw damage from the storm as he drove up Interstate 75 between Beaverdam and Bluffton, with overturned trucks and cars as well as other debris on the highway for nearly a mile. The husband of some relatives who lived just east of Lima observed the storm’s passage from a patio door as the rest of the family huddled in their basement. He said as soon as the storm passed to his northeast the stars came out and he knew it was all over, everything would be fine.

It appears this particular supercell of the 1965 Palm Sunday Outbreak, which generated the Allen County tornado, originated more than two hours earlier southeast of Lafayette, Indiana, and moved, under the influence of unusually strong upper level jet stream wind, east-northeast at speeds of over sixty miles per hour. It appeared to be what is now termed a cyclical supercell that generated many separate, strong, multi-vortex tornadoes. Its nearly 275-mile path ended near Cleveland, Ohio. Across Indiana it leveled the towns of Russiaville, Alto, southern sections of Kokomo, Greentown, southern sections of Marion, and areas near Berne before crossing into Ohio. Once Ohio was the target, the twister passed just north of Rockford, south of Van Wert, and just south of Delphos as it entered Allen County. At that point the storm reorganized, producing a new F-4 vortex just northwest of Elida. This corresponded to the explosive increase in lightning intensity we observed as the storm was passing to our north. Moving along at nearly sixty miles per hour, the tornado destroyed everything in its path, with the little village of Cairo its next pending victim. Mercifully, the tornado lifted just west of the town and set down again just to the northeast, sparing the community major damage.

Relentlessly, the funnel pressed on toward Interstate 75. A railroad parallels the highway between Beaverdam and Bluffton with a deep ditch between the road and tracks. It appears this ditch caught or disrupted the tornado’s circulation enough to divert it to the northeast, where it wreaked havoc with any vehicle on the highway for about a mile. Finally it jumped the road and, reassuming its east-northeast path, moved out of the county.

I observed firsthand the damage two weeks later, when the public was finally allowed into the storm track area. Our family took a Sunday drive following the damage path from west to east. I saw things that were both frightening and fascinating. Many homes were totally destroyed; some still had walls but no roof; vehicles of all types lay scattered across fields, along with bits and pieces of people’s lives. High-voltage transmission towers lay twisted flat on the ground, and an electrical substation was totally wiped out; these were likely the sources of the blue flashes I saw to our north the night of the tornadoes.

I was most impressed with the foundation of an old farm house, wiped clean by the wind, with an upright piano still standing in the open air. Once part of a family fixture in a living room, now the piano was the only a remnant of the home that had once stood there.

It is interesting how a single event can be pivotal in our lives even at a young age. So it was for me with the Palm Sunday Outbreak of 1965. At first my fear of thunderstorms increased. Every year I felt a dread of April and springtime; I imagined that each storm that came up could be like that evening, except this time the funnel would get us. Time passed, and my fear evolved into a great respect for weather in general and deep interest in severe thunderstorms and hurricanes in particular—how and why they form. Still, after nearly forty-four years, there are times when I think back to that weekend and recall the feelings and emotions, remembering those who were adversely affected by the events of that weekend in April, 1965.

Fog and Ice in Caledonia, Michigan

Freezing rain. Black ice. Fog. January 4, 2009, has been a bit of a departure from the snowy, arctic blasts we”d been getting up till last week, when a warm intrusion brought rain and even thunderstorms through the area. Since then the temperatures, though cold, haven”t been bitterly cold, and today they”ve hovered right around freezing.

I brought my camera with me to church this morning with the thought that I”d grab a few moody fog photographs afterward. Here are a couple.

Half a mile from me, on the outskirts of town, lies a small lake surrounded by a tamarack bog and swamp. I thought the setting might offer some cool, misty shots, and it did.

On the way home, heading north on 100th Street, the overarching trees combined with the fog to provided a mysterious tunnel effect. I love how this looks!

Today’s slippery conditions have provided a perfect case in point for a recent discussion on Stormtrack about the effectiveness of National Weather Service wording for hazardous winter weather. So far, conditions haven’t been nearly as bad as I”ve seen them get. But then, this is Michigan; because we get icy highways as a matter of course, we’re prepared for the worst. Things get bad, we salt the heck out of the roads.

I can’t say how that has worked today, though, since I’ve pretty much hunkered down and stayed inside this afternoon. This is a good day for lying low and doing computer work. So here I am, blogging.

Of course, there are other diversions besides. Stormtrack has been keeping me entertained with two virtual chase scenarios running concurrently. This has afforded me the odd experience of waiting for convective initiation in York, Nebraska, and Wichita Falls, Texas, at the same time. I get around. Now if just one of these setups pops, I”ll be a happy camper.

WaterlandLiving.com: Where I Blog When I’m Not Blogging Here

Yesterday I posted an article on shear funnels at WaterlandLiving.com. Waterland is my “other blog.” Well, not mine really. It belongs to Dave VanderVeen, owner of Waterland Homes LLC, and it is devoted to all things Michigan.

Some of the stuff written by Dave contains just plain savvy insights on homes and real estate. But the blog as a whole is about outdoor Michigan. That’s no surprise, since Dave has followed a different path in home building and real estate, focusing on properties out in the country. Hunting cabins, lakeside homes, lodges, campgrounds…Waterland is where to go when you”re ready to trade suburbia for something closer to the land, to the fields, lakes, and woods of Michigan.

Yes, that”s a shameless plug for Waterland Homes. I get to do that kind of thing on this site. Never mind that—check out the blog. If you live in Michigan or in any of the Great Lakes states and love the outdoors, I think you”ll like what you find. The site is rich in images and packed with items of interest for nature lovers, fishermen, hunters, hikers, and backroads wanderers who love to see what”s over the hill and around the bend.

Tamarack Needles

Fridays are my day on WaterlandLiving. Six days of the week, Dave provides a more factual approach. My mission is to offer a bit of literary ambience—to take you to places you wouldn’t think to go, open your eyes to things you might pass by…to engage your senses so that you experience different aspects of the outdoors, and perhaps enjoy a chuckle or two in the process.

Riff through my Friday posts and you’re liable to come across just about anything under—or in—the Michigan sky. You’ll find articles on

* Michigan backroads

* carnivorous plants

* poison ivy and poison sumac—and what it’s like to eat them!

* railroads

* thunderstorms

* topwater fishing

* wild orchids

* hummingbirds

* sassafras tea

* what makes the leaves turn color

* hunting knives

* Hunter”s Moon and other monthly moon names

* wild cranberries

* winter photography

Hummingbird Feeder

The list goes on, and since it continues to grow, you’re apt to find just about anything in it, as long as it’s got to do with the outdoors and Michigan. So if you love the smell of white pine and woodsmoke…if the sudden thunder of grouse wings stirs something inside you…if a moontrail on the waters awakens your sense of wonder…then drop in.

Moonrise Over Gun Lake

I might add that Dave is getting set to launch a second blogsite devoted to the Lake Michigan shoreline. We’ll be exploring state parks, wineries and brewpubs, nature preserves, out-of-the-way restaurants, bed-and-breakfasts, harbor communities, and other points of interest along Michigan”s west coast. So stay tuned—I’ll let you know when the site is up and running.

A Post-Christmas Severe Weather Outbreak? It Just Might Happen.

Now, here’s something you don”t normally expect on the day after Christmas…

Them there is dewpoints, folks–juicy, 55-degree-plus dewpoints stretching as far north as Saint Louis, Missouri, by 18z Friday, and Renselaar, Indiana, by 00z Friday night. And Saturday gets even crazier, pulling a mid-fifties fetch well into Michigan.

With wind fields and helicities every bit as wild as you’d expect for this time of year, this could be the ultimate in late-season storm chasing, or in early-season action, depending on how you do your books.

Several days ago I was just crossing my fingers. I’m still keeping them crossed, but with the WRF now chiming in to corroborate what the GFS has been consistently depicting, I think it’s time to practice saying the words, “severe weather outbreak.” Today’s SPC extended outlook agrees:

WITH A GENERAL CONSENSUS OF MODEL SOLUTIONS LEADING CREDENCE TO THE POSSIBILITY OF 60 F DEWPOINTS MAKING IT AS FAR NORTH AS THE MIDDLE MISSISSIPPI/OHIO VALLEY BY DAY 5/SATURDAY. IN ALL…CURRENT THINKING IS THAT A MULTIFACETED/ALL HAZARDS SEVERE RISK WILL MATERIALIZE ACROSS PORTIONS OF FAR EASTERN OK/OZARKS/ARKLATEX TO THE MIDDLE MISSISSIPPI VALLEY/OHIO VALLEY FOR DAY 4/FRIDAY INTO DAY 5/SATURDAY.

I’m currently considering St. Louis south toward the bootheel, possibly into Arkansas, and hoping that the next run or two nudges Friday’s setup just a shade to the east and north. Bill and I are talking about taking off around midnight Christmas night, and Kurt may join us if he is able.

At this point, I think it”s safe to say we’re in for a winter outbreak that could stretch as far north as central Illinois and Indiana. Should be interesting.

Looking for that perfect, last-minute Christmas gift for the storm chaser in your life? Consider giving a tasteful holiday package of backing winds, veering upper levels, and a little mixed layer CAPE–perfect as a stocking stuffer, and sure to be appreciated by Midwest chasers this Friday and Saturday.

Near-Blizzard Conditions in Michigan on Winter Solstice

“Near blizzard conditions” is what KGRR is calling it. I call it a good, old-fashioned Michigan snowstorm, the kind I remember from my boyhood down in Niles. Seems like such storms started to peter out once my family moved to Grand Rapids back in 1968, though I remember we still got a few good, solid blasts. It has been a long time, though, since I’ve seen a December like this one. Last year”s winter set a record for snow accumulation; this year”s looks well on its way to becoming another record-breaker, if it isn”t one already.

Here is the view from my apartment onto my deck.

The two mushroom-like objects on the bottom left are pots of chicken soup, thoroughly frozen. On days like today, I like to chisel out a nice chunk and enjoy it at my leisure. Explosives could accelerate the process, but out of consideration for my neighbors, I refrain and use an air hammer instead. It”s a more time-consuming approach, but it”s worth it. There’s nothing like a good, hearty slab of chicken soup on a blustery winter day, that’s what I say.

Where was I, anyway? Oh, yes–near-blizzard conditions. I have to agree with the NWS on that one. Here”s a view of the parking lot.

Nothing about that picture says “tank top and shorts.” The current station reading at 11:30 a.m. shows 11 degrees Fahrenheit, winds of 24 miles an hour gusting to 33, and a wind chill of -9. If you”ve ever felt an urge to go streaking down Main Street, today would not be the day. No, this is the kind of day when you can hunker down inside with a cup of hot tea and feel totally guiltless about doing absolutely nothing.

It seems particularly fitting that we’re getting a major winter storm on the day of the winter solstice. Today isn’t just the snowiest day of the year so far, it”s also the shortest. From here on, we begin the slow but encouraging trek toward spring. Winter has just begun and–though, looking out the window, the thought seems unbelievable–the worst still lies ahead. Three months of ice, slush, flying snow spray, slippery roads, and bitter cold. But we’ve finally descended to the utmost depth of the long nights, and now we’re heading back for the sunny surface. March, the transitional month, isn”t that terribly far away. And amazingly, we may get a crack at a storm chase as near as next week in southern Illinois and Indiana.

This last chase season got off to an early start on January 7, and then a month later on February 5 with the Super Tuesday Outbreak. So who knows what next weekend will hold. I”m not holding my breath, but I am crossing my fingers.

Historical Tornadoes: Remembering the Worst of the Worst

Every year, scores of tornadoes roam the United States. Probably the better part of them have minimal to no human impact, but there are always a fair number that inflict damage, injury, and even death. Some hit a farm or two; others sweep through communities, tearing up homes. No matter how you cut it, they’re bad news, and the people affected by them will never forget the experience.

Once in a great while, though, a tornado comes along whose ferocity and the toll it inflicts on communities set it apart into the upper echelon–that rare one percent which comprise the absolute worst of the worst. There is a uniquely horrifying, haunting, and almost mythical quality about such extreme storms. The great grand-daddy of them all is, of course, the Great Tri-State Tornado of 1925. But there are others, usually known by the town they destroyed. Woodward, Oklahoma. Xenia, Ohio. Topeka, Kansas. Dunlap, Indiana. Moore, Oklahoma. Greensburg, Kansas. Plainfield, Illinois. Wichita Falls, Texas. Saint Louis, Missouri. Flint, Michigan. Worcester, Massachusetts. The list continues.

Many of these monsters, such as the Tri-State and Woodward tornadoes, have no photographic record of the actual storm. Lots of damage photos, but nothing that shows the actual funnel. Others, dating at least back into the early 1950s with the Worcester tornado, were captured on camera.

Many of these storms were a part of larger outbreaks, including such notorious, massive events as the 1974 Super Outbreak, the 1965 Palm Sunday Outbreak, and the 1999 Central Oklahoma Outbreak. Others, such as the Flint-Beecher tornado, occurred as the worst of a relative handful of tornadoes.

Regardless of its unique circumstances, each storm stands apart in terms of property damage, intensity, and either loss of life or, in some cases, a surprisingly low mortality rate given the circumstances. Most notably, the supercell that spawned the 1.7-mile-wide 2007 Greensburg, Kansas, tornado may have also generated the largest tornado ever recorded. Over four miles wide at cloud base, the radar-detected circulation may forever remain a subject of speculation as to whether its tornado-force winds actually reached the ground, but it seems reasonable to think that they could have.

I’ve had the good fortune to chase the historical Six State Supercell, and the exhilarating but disturbing experience of locking onto the tornado following the EF-5 that wiped out a third of Parkersburg, Iowa. But a truly historical tornado, in the league of Greensburg or Moore? Not yet. Hopefully never. I don”t want to witness that kind of carnage. It”s bound to happen from time to time. Thank goodness, such occurrences are uncommon. The part of me that is fascinated with tornadoes would like to score such a coup. But another part of me which recognizes what that implies hopes I never get the chance to see something so awful. I have friends whose lives were terribly impacted by just such an event. I can’t imagine going through something like that, or witnessing it in progress. Metaphorically, it’s one thing to film lions in the wild; it”s another to watch one maul a fellow human being.

A Winter of Contrasts

Yesterday I drove out to an area near the Coldwater River in extreme southeast Kent County and returned with the following photos among many.

Ice and Snow

Linear

I just showed you those shots because I felt like it. Also, though, to give you an idea of what a mixed bag this December is proving to be. While snow has been the rule up here in the frozen tundra of Michgan, the Gulf has been doing brisk business farther south. Pulling juicy dewpoints northwards and combining them with high helicities and good bulk shear, a low has been firing off severe thunderstorms and tornadoes across the Dixie Alley. In fact, Wednesday’s tally shows twenty-two tornadoes spread across Mississippi, Louisiana, and Alabama. Perhaps that figure will be modified, but I”m simply impressed with the fact that there were any tornadoes at all. Up here in the land of ice and snow, such phenomena seem like mere pipe dreams.

But who knows what this winter has in store for us. The last one held a few surprises. In Michigan, the surprise so far has been the massive amount of snow that has already been deposited on the landscape. It”s not a bad thing; the Great Lakes water levels can use another good, snowy winter of the kind we got last year, and as a new enthusiast of winter photography, I don’t mind so much if we get one. But I can still hardly wait for March, and the first rumblings of serious convection. Bring it on, I say. The sooner, the better.

Snow Photography at Maher Audubon Sanctuary

Today was my second winter photo expedition, and I returned from it more impressed than ever with the stunning possibilities that reside in a snow-clad landscape. It was after 3:00 p.m. when I headed out to the Maher Audubon Sanctuary on 108th Street near the Coldwater River. The afternoon sun had that marvelous slant to it that brings out the gold in the light, and long shadows stretched through the woods and added drama to the snowscape.

Once again I’ll conserve my words and let a few images tell the story.

Frozen Swamp

Cattails

Snow Sculpture

Tree Trunk

Freezing Rain in Michigan, Big Storms in Texas

Freezing rain has been on the menu for this evening here in lower Michigan, but it looks to be transitioning to plain old rain as surface temperatures warm into the thirties. My friend Lisa and I were up in Stanton earlier, visiting the Beshadas, and I expected an icy drive home, but it didn”t turn out that way. Driving was fine. And now, seeing that rain is in the forecast rather than snow, I’ve had the pleasure of switching the reflectivity table on my radar from winter mode to rain mode. I take my joys where I can find them. This is a fleeting one, but kinda nice. Temps are forecast for the thirties into tomorrow, but drop back into the twenties by Wednesday.

Meanwhile, severe thunderstorms have been scooting across Texas and Oklahoma. A line of embedded supercells produced at least one tornado warning earlier. The storms now have transitioned to a couple small lines with bowing sections plus “scrap” storms, and overall things seem to be weakening.

Today has been an active weather day both north and south, and more appears to be in store for tomorrow. Gotta love this time of year!

Alberta Clipper: A Michigan Snow Slam

The low has lifted off to the northeast into Canada and the skies are clear, but the wind is still lashing powdery snow across the landscape as the tail end of an Alberta Clipper reluctantly eases its grip on Michigan. From what I can judge looking at RUC and NAM, the winds should die down by late morning or early afternoon tomorrow as a high moves into the area.

Here’s what the system looked like on GR2 earlier today.

Of course, this is just the radar at KGRR; a regional composite would depict the system in its entirety. It hasn”t been as bad as I”d anticipated, but it has still dumped a lot of snow. Taken all around, we are experiencing what I would call a good, old-fashioned Michigan winter–the real deal, the way things used to be. We got one of those last year, too. And it won”t be such a bad thing if we get another one. The Great Lakes water levels could stand another good injection of snowmelt, and the way the season has started, they look to be getting one.

Having just discovered how rewarding winter photography can be, I”m curious to see what the season holds. Tonight, having driven home from a gig, I can safely say that black ice and cold temperatures are a part of the mix. But that”s just part of the price tag for living in Michigan, and there are compensations. I”ll be standing by with my camera, hoping to make the most of the snowy season.